Thank you for purchasing through links and ads on this site.
OWC / MacSales.com...
diglloyd Deal Finder...
Buy other stuff at Amazon.com...
Upgrade the memory of your 2018 Mac mini up to 64GB
877-865-7002
Today’s Deal Zone Items... Handpicked deals...
$1399 $1199
SAVE $200

$120 $40
SAVE $80

$849 $599
SAVE $250

$610 $444
SAVE $165

$1299 $999
SAVE $300

$299 $169
SAVE $130

$2799 $2499
SAVE $300

$1499 $899
SAVE $600

$799 $639
SAVE $160

$1180 $1050
SAVE $130

$150 $90
SAVE $60

$2399 $2159
SAVE $240

$1999 $1799
SAVE $200

$1099 $929
SAVE $170

$220 $170
SAVE $50

$1199 $1079
SAVE $120

$599 $199
SAVE $400

$819 $649
SAVE $170

$348 $298
SAVE $50

$2799 $2149
SAVE $650

$750 $450
SAVE $300

$1099 $929
SAVE $170

$280 $225
SAVE $55

$1299 $1169
SAVE $130

$998 $498
SAVE $500

Mac Pro Westmere Real World Memory Bandwidth

Last updated 2010-09-05 - Send Feedback
Related: bandwidth, Mac Pro, Macs, memory, memory bandwidth

See test machine configuration.

The memory bandwidth test uses MemoryTester, the numbers are from the stress command. The 'stress' command uses all virtual cores at once for 100% CPU utilization. It is a pure memory-speed-bound test.

Theoretical benefits

The MemoryTester number is a true measure of the ability of a real program to utilize the memory system. Small differences should be ignored as there is some fractional measurement error.

  • Though 1333MHz memory should offer 25% more bandwidth to a real program, testing shows that the gain is only 10% for a real program.
  • Using 1066Mhz memory in the 2010 3.33GHz Mac Pro (1333MHz is stipulated) results in identical memory speed to the 2009 3.33GHz Mac Pro.
  • An 8-core or 12-core system has dual banks of memory, hence greater bandwidth.

Yes, you can use one (1) 8GB module in the hexacore Mac Pro, but the memory bandwidth is severely reduced. Not recommended, but two modules OK.

Click to view a larger graph.

Memory bandwidth as measured by MemoryTester 'stress' command

Does it matter for real tasks?!

Memory bandwidth differences are hard to measure with real program doing real tasks because the on-chip caches mask the effects, and most programs are not memory-access intensive.

To find out if memory bandwidth would actually matter for common tasks, including memory intensive ones, such as Photoshop. I chose the diglloydSpeed1 benchmark, and tested with 2/3/4 modules in the 3.33GHz 6-core Mac Pro. This test has plenty of memory even with 2 modules, so the amount of memory is not a factor.

  • The test took 2.7% longer with two modules as compared with three.
  • The test took 2.4% longer with four modules as compared with three.
  • I also tested with Helicon Focus and Photozoom Pro. No difference between 2 or 3 modules.

If you want maximum speed, stick with three modules. But remember, if memory runs low, more memory is far faster than too little and these small differences seen here are irrelevant.

diglloydSpeed1 using 2 X 8GB or 3 X 8GB

 


Save the tax, we pay you back, instantly!
View all handpicked deals...

ezviz CV-200 Mini Plus 1080p Wi-Fi Camera with Night Vision & 16GB microSD Card (Black)
$120 $40
SAVE $80

diglloyd.com | Terms of Use | PRIVACY POLICY
Contact | About Lloyd Chambers | Consulting | Photo Tours
Mailing Lists | RSS Feeds | Twitter
Copyright © 2020 diglloyd Inc, all rights reserved.
Display info: __RETINA_INFO_STATUS__