Thank you for purchasing through links and ads on this site.
diglloyd Deal Finder...
Buy other stuff at
Upgrade the memory of your 2018 Mac mini up to 64GB

Save As Command Forces Multi-Step Workaround, Data Destruction

Last updated 2011-12-27 - Send Feedback
Related: macOS

Status: still broken in Mac OS X Lion 10.7.2. Continues to interfere with efficient workflow each and every day. More infuriating than ever, especially when opening read only files (e.g., PDF) that one wants to save-as. Or template files that one wants to save-as. Also effectively DESTROYS DATA, because the duplicate often results in my editing the wrong file, forcing a tedious restore of the original. This is the most idiotic user interface change Apple has made in years.

Update 2012-08-04 for OS X Mountain Lion: there is now a shortcut to replicate Save As with a FILE OVERWRITE BUG: if one edits a document than does Save As (cmd-option-shift-S in Pages for example), then BOTH the edited original document and the copy are saved, thus not only saving a new copy, but silently saving the original with the same changes, thus silently destroying the original version.

I often open a Pages document (or other kinds), then hit cmd-shift-S to save a new document with a different name, which I then edit.

When one does such things 10 or 20 times a day, it quickly becomes an efficiency issue to have extra steps.

Upgrade Your Mac Memory
At much lower cost than Apple, with more options.
Lloyd recommends 64GB for iMac or Mac Pro for photography/videography.

My old workflow on Snow Leopard:

Quick and efficient.

  1. Type cmd-shift-S.
  2. Enter the revised or new name, lick the Save button.
Save As no longer exists

The inefficient Mac OS X Lion workflow.

In which the Save As no longer exists, this approach doubles the number of steps required, and requires using the mouse.

  1. Choose File => Duplicate
    (mouse required, no command key shortcut).
  2. Switch to the original window and close it, possibly also having to respond to a “Save Changes” dialog.
  3. Type cmd-S to save the document.
  4. Enter the revised or new name, lick the Save button. Except that maybe the folder is the wrong place, so navigate around, wasting more time.

Whoever designs such things at Apple has a warped conceptual faculty— design elegance means keeping simple things simple, not making them frustrating with more steps that take more time.

Adding a command key shortcut for Duplicate would help a tiny bit, but event that cannot be done because there are two Duplicate commands in pages (one in File and one in Edit); it simply will not work.

Mike M writes

It’s actually worse, sometimes—

In your delineation of the steps necessary in Lion to do the Save As that was so easy in Snow Leopard, you actually left out an additional step.

When you do a Save As in Snow Leopard, the dialog box that pops up points to the same location as the document you're working on. (While it's not universally so, seems to me in most cases you would want to save a duplicated document in the same folder as the original.)

But in Lion, when you first save the duplicated file, the dialog box defaults to the "last used" location, which in most cases has nothing to do with the document you've duplicated, and indeed may have nothing to do with the application you're working in.

So you need to add an additional step between Step 3 and Step 4 of your "The inefficient Mac OS X Lion workflow":

3a. Navigate to the location where you want to save your duplicated document.

The web is rife with complaints from people like me, who have had a workflow of XX years (23, in my case) ruined by the boneheaded decision to eliminate Save As. Do you think Apple will listen, or just plow ahead in their "We know what's best for you better than you do" arrogance?

DIGLLOYD MPG: It’s not just that the workflow has changed— something we all like to gripe about, since it damages productivity unless the change give back some in reducing the tedium. It’s that it has changed for the much worse. All signs indicate that we’re stuck with an idiotic decision. Of course, any individual application written by an intelligent developer can bypass this folly, but who knows whether Apple will require adherence in order to approve an App for the App Store?

128GB Memory in iMac 5K

Up to 128GB for 2019 iMac 5K!
Up to 64GB for 2015/2017 iMac 5K

Save nearly 50% over Apple pricing
Apple MacBook 12-inch, Mid 2017 (Current Model)

$1599 Only $999

1.3 GHz i5, 8GB, 512GB SSD
Apple Refurbished, Factory Sealed, Apple 1 Year Limited Warranty
B&H Deal ZoneDeals by Brand/Category/Savings
Deals expire in 20 hours unless noted. Certain deals may last longer.
$2797 SAVE $600 = 17.0% Nikon Z 7 Mirrorless in Cameras: Mirrorless
$2798 SAVE $400 = 12.0% Sony a7R III Mirrorless in Cameras: Mirrorless
$3498 SAVE $1000 = 22.0% Sony a9 Mirrorless in Cameras: Mirrorless
$898 SAVE $100 = 10.0% $164 FREE ITEMS Sony DSC-RX100 VA in Cameras: Point and Shoot
$1879 SAVE $1071 = 36.0% ZEISS 15mm f/2.8 Distagon T* ZE in Lenses: DSLR | Terms of Use | PRIVACY POLICY
Contact | About Lloyd Chambers | Consulting | Photo Tours
Mailing Lists | RSS Feeds | Twitter
Copyright © 2019 diglloyd Inc, all rights reserved.
Display info: __RETINA_INFO_STATUS__