OWC 40TB SSD: RAID-4 vs RAID-5

2016-11-25 • SEND FEEDBACK •
Related: Other World Computing, OWC Thunderbay, OWC ThunderBay 4, OWC Thunderbay 4 Mini, RAID, RAID-4, RAID-5, SoftRAID, SSD, storage, Thunderbolt, video, weather events

OWC Thunderbay Mini

The Thunderbay 4 Mini RAID-5 edition is available with SSDs in capacities from 1TB to 40TB. MPG strong recommends the RAID edition.

Thunderbay 4 Mini configurations (non RAID) are also available, as well as hard drive configurations are also available.

RAID-5 and RAID-4 are two sides of the same coin: both offer the fault tolerance of surviving failure of one of the drives in the array.

The difference is that RAID-4 dedicates one drive to the parity data, and RAID-5 uses distributed parity data. While the fault tolerance and recovery behavior is identical, the performance is not necessarily same, as MPG proved back in 2014 with other SSDs in the OWC Thunderbay 4 Mini.

Performance potential

The best possible performance one can expect from RAID-4/RAID-5 consisting of N drives is the performance of N-1 drives in a RAID-0 stripe.

The performance as measured in testing closely approaches that asymptote. Many if not most hardware RAID solutions often fail to do anywhere near that well.

Results, large transfers over entire capacity

This is the best 4-drive RAID-5 and RAID-4 performance MPG has ever seen with Thunderbolt 2 (or from any external SSD). It sets the new benchmark. The RAID-5 and RAID-4 performances is outstanding in two ways:

• Flat line consistency across the entire 29.8TB volume.
• Data rates within a few percent of the theoretical speed.

While RAID-4 and RAID-5 offer identical write performance, RAID-4 outperforms RAID-5 by 16% for reads.

Based on single-SSD testing, MPG had estimated the peak potential performance of the OWC 40TB SSD (were if not throttled by Thunderbolt 2) at about 1650 MB/sec. 75% of that is the maximum possible performance, or 1237MB/sec estimated. Since RAID-4 as tested here delivers 1224 MB/sec, SoftRAID’s RAID-4 mode appears to offer the maximum possible theoretical performance.

Tested using a> disktester fill-volume --xfer 128M with diglloydTools disktester

RAID-4: Write @ 814 MiB/sec = 853 MB/sec, Read @ 1167 MiB/sec = 1224 MB/sec
RAID-5: Write @ 814 MiB/sec = 854 MB/sec, Read @ 1003 MiB/sec = 1052 MB/sec

Graph data is for filling the volume to 99% capacity with 1000 test files.

Sustained transfer performance with a 30TB RAID-4 vs RAID-5 SSD configuration in OWC Thunderbay 4 Mini

Results, speed vs transfer size

SoftRAID’s RAID-4 and RAID-5 modes offer identical write performance, but RAID-4 shows not only more consistency but higher performance at every transfer size 64K or larger.

RAID-4 mode is the unequivocal winner over RAID-5 (blue vs green lines).

a> disktester run-sequential-suite -s 32 -3 512M --iterations 5 --test-size 4G

Sustained transfer performance with a 30TB RAID-4 vs RAID-5 SSD configuration in OWC Thunderbay 4 Mini

CLICK TO VIEW: OWC Huge External SSDs