First to check out, first served. Open box, used, replacement, even new priced to move!
The Fastest 2TB Volume is on a 4TB Drive
See Why You Need More Space Than You Need for the reasons why hard drives slow down as they fill up.
Drives aren’t useful when empty; we fill them up with stuff, like a huge closet!
The fastest 2TB of hard drive storage is on the largest capacity drive
Update, early 2015: see also 4/5/6TB Hard Drives: Higher Capacity Boosts Real-World Performance.
Assuming the same rotational rate and similar technology, the fastest 2TB of storage is on the largest capacity drive, by simple math (rpm, circumference and data density).
Supposing your storage needs are less than 2TB (or 1TB or 3TB, whatever). Suppose also that you value high performance, especially for new data (e.g., images) that you are adding regularly.
As a drive fills up, all your new stuff, the stuff you’re working on (such as new pictures), is stored onto the slowest part of the drive, because the faster parts of the drive have already been filled up.
This is true not just for sequential I/O speed (reading/writing large files), but also for seek time, because the higher capacity drive stores the same amount of data in fewer tracks, which requires shorter physical movements of the drive heads.
The graph below compares three Hitachi 7200 rpm hard drives, using a 2TB partition on each drive:
Observe the big picture: the 2TB partition on a 4TB drive is fastest by far. The 4TB drive also offers more consistent speed than the 3TB or 2TB drives.
The 2TB partition on the 3TB drive is slower than on the 4TB drive, but faster than the 2TB drive.
Click for a larger graph.