MPG Table of Contents   Page 1: Introduction Page 2: Seagate Momentus 7200.4 500GB Page 3: Fujitsu 320GB Page 4: Intel 80GB X25-M SSD Page 5: Hitachi 500GB Travelstar 5K500.B Page 6: Hitachi 320GB Travelstar 7K320 Page 7: Seagate 160GB Momentus 7200.2 Page 8: Seagate 320GB Momentus 7200.3 Page 9: Western Digital 320GB Scorpio Black Page 10: Western Digital 500GB Scorpio Blue

Seagate 160GB Momentus 7200.2

The mid-2007-vintage 160GB Seagate Momentus 7200.2 is a dithering performer by comparison to 2008-vintage 320GB drives. See the results for the Hitachi 320GB Travelstar, which average about 40% faster.

If you have this drive or other vintage 2007 drive in your MacBook or MacBook Pro, upgrade it now to the Hitachi 320GB Travelstar for about $89 after rebate.

Raw data

Test mule: MacBook Pro (2007) 2.4GHz 
SATA hardware: FirmTek SeriTek/2SM2-E + NewerTech Voyager
Driver: Apple standard
Drive model: ST9160823AS


# test via eSATA
$ disktester run-area-test -i 3 -c 1M -t 1G  Seagate160

===  Monday, November 24, 2008 9:35:10 AM PT, volume "Seagate160" (148.7GB)  ===

------------ Write Details for "Seagate160" (1GB/32MB, 3 iterations) -----------
Area (146.7GB)    Slowest    Median    Fastest    Average    Range
       0%           53.7      54.3       55.0       54.3      1.31
      10%           54.5      54.9       55.0       54.8      0.48
      20%           53.1      53.9       54.0       53.7      0.96
      30%           51.7      52.0       52.4       52.0      0.64
      40%           49.2      49.8       50.1       49.7      0.84
      50%           46.1      46.5       46.9       46.5      0.75
      60%           44.1      44.3       44.3       44.2      0.20
      70%           41.7      41.8       41.8       41.8      0.13
      80%           37.8      37.8       37.9       37.8      0.18
      90%           32.9      32.9       32.9       32.9      0.02
     100%           45.9      45.9       46.3       46.1      0.41

------------ Read Details for "Seagate160" (1GB/32MB, 3 iterations) ------------
Area (146.7GB)    Slowest    Median    Fastest    Average    Range
       0%           58.0      58.0       58.4       58.1      0.38
      10%           56.1      56.4       56.4       56.3      0.31
      20%           54.1      54.3       54.3       54.3      0.24
      30%           52.1      52.3       52.4       52.3      0.29
      40%           49.8      50.1       50.1       50.0      0.28
      50%           46.5      46.5       46.7       46.6      0.25
      60%           44.0      44.2       44.2       44.1      0.19
      70%           41.5      41.7       41.7       41.7      0.18
      80%           37.7      37.8       37.8       37.8      0.15
      90%           32.7      32.7       32.7       32.7      0.01
     100%           47.8      48.0       48.0       47.9      0.26

-------------- Averages for "Seagate160" (1GB/32MB, 3 iterations) --------------
Area (146.7GB)    Write MB/sec    Read MB/sec
       0%             54.3            58.1   
      10%             54.8            56.3   
      20%             53.7            54.3   
      30%             52.0            52.3   
      40%             49.7            50.0   
      50%             46.5            46.6   
      60%             44.2            44.1   
      70%             41.8            41.7   
      80%             37.8            37.8   
      90%             32.9            32.7   
     100%             46.1            47.9   <== erroneous
Average write speed across the volume: 46.7MB/sec
Average read speed across the volume: 47.4MB/sec