Thank you for purchasing through links and ads on this site.
diglloyd Deal Finder...
Buy other stuff at
Upgrade the memory of your 2018 Mac mini up to 64GB
Handpicked deals...
$4499 $2649
SAVE $1850

$1699 $1199
SAVE $500

$5999 $5499
SAVE $500

$181 $110
SAVE $71

$7699 $7199
SAVE $500

$4499 $2649
SAVE $1850

$400 $330
SAVE $70

$4499 $2649
SAVE $1850

$4999 $4599
SAVE $400

$2350 $1950
SAVE $400

$1699 $1299
SAVE $400

$799 $699
SAVE $100

$200 $157
SAVE $43

$1997 $897
SAVE $1100

$250 $110
SAVE $140

$1398 $898
SAVE $500

$1199 $1099
SAVE $100

$3999 $2499
SAVE $1500

$200 $170
SAVE $30

$3999 $2499
SAVE $1500

$1498 $1398
SAVE $100

$2497 $1897
SAVE $600

$748 $598
SAVE $150

$899 $699
SAVE $200

$1300 $1100
SAVE $200

Nehalem Cores vs. Clock Speed: Digital Camera RAW-file Processing

Last updated 2010-05-13 - Send Feedback
Related: Lightroom, Mac Pro, RAW, raw file processing

This test measures digital camera RAW file processing speed with various converters. All tests repeated to cross-check.


Software engineering matters.

CaptureONE Pro offers a 21% reduction in processing time on the 8-core 2.93GHz, taking 26% longer on the 3.33Ghz quad-core.

Lightroom 2.7 is 40% slower on the 8-core! More is less. This is apparently due to a memory leak bug, which I have previously observed on an 8 core Mac Pro. LR 2.7 scarfed up 2GB more memory than on the quad-core (and LR 3 did not). I repeated the test 3 times, each time with the same results. LR 2.7 also slows down with more files (I estimate 2-3 days to process ~5000 files when the bug occurs ).

Lightroom 3 beta ekes out a measly 3% gain on the 8-core While better than LR 2.7, it is very disappointing showing that Lightroom is not engineered to use more than 4 cores.

Aperture 3 is 19% slower on the 8 core.

Digital Photo Professional is essentially the same speed on both models.

RAW Developer is 9% slower on the 8 core and its speed is in line with the clock speed difference. Not surprising, since it is single-threaded.

Observe also the absolute time for the conversions: LR 3 beta is very fast compared to the other converters, even if it does not use an 8-core machine efficiently. It’s a pity it does not scale to 8 cores.

Time in seconds, lower is faster.
Click for larger graph.

Software engineering is the bottleneck

None of the RAW-file converters make full use of CPU resources. Put simply, this is the result of poor software engineering, notwithstanding the lame excuses you’re bound to hear from software vendors.

For the Mac-bashers out there: this is not an OS X limitation at all. There are well written programs that do make full use of all available cores, and two of them are included in this report.

New Mac Pro?

Or iMac 5K or iMac Pro?
Consult with Lloyd ASAP before buying!

System configuration for CPU, GPU, memory, SSD, backup, RAID, optimizing performance, workflow.
For YOUR optimal workflow

Avoid costly mistakes in throwing money at the problem for less performance and/or buying the wrong machine for your own needs!

Remote screen sharing available for RAID, software configuration, etc.

More about 2019 Mac Pro vs iMac 5K vs iMac Pro...

Even the simple solution is not used

In the simplest approach, programs could process one RAW file per CPU core, with a worker thread delivering I/O services— but none of them do. They all are brain-dead on the algorithm: process one file at a time, in sequence. It’s an idiotic algorithm for a multi-core world.

Most of the programs use multiple threads, but with disappointing efficiency; they just do not scale beyond a few threads. The inefficiency is not related to disk I/O, both by observation as well as having these tests run on the fastest possible internal disk setup.

This lack of attention to efficiency is an engineering misfeasance in today’s market of multi-core computers where time is money for many professionals. Witness the stupid trick for DPP and stupid trick for Lightroom proving that if only there were a will to do so, performance could be raised natively.

Deals Updated Daily at B&H Photo
View all handpicked deals...

Apple 13.3" MacBook Pro (Mid 2017, Space Gray)
$1699 $1199
SAVE $500 | Terms of Use | PRIVACY POLICY
Contact | About Lloyd Chambers | Consulting | Photo Tours
Mailing Lists | RSS Feeds | Twitter
Copyright © 2020 diglloyd Inc, all rights reserved.
Display info: __RETINA_INFO_STATUS__