↝ OWC / MacSales.com... ↜
↝ diglloyd Deal Finder... ↜
Buy other stuff at Amazon.com...
Consult with Lloyd today—
System configuration for CPU, GPU, memory, SSD, backup, RAID, optimizing performance, workflow.
For YOUR optimal workflow
Avoid costly mistakes in throwing money at the problem for less performance and/or buying the wrong machine for your own needs!
Thunderbolt vs USB3 Performance as RAID-0 Stripe
Related: Other World Computing, RAID, RAID-0, storage, Thunderbolt, Toshiba, USB
To assess Thunderbolt vs USB3, a RAID-0 stripe configuration was used (double capacity, double speed vs a single drive metric).
A 1TB partition was made on the fastest 1/6 0f the drives (3 X 2TB = 6GB) in order to compare Thunderbolt to USB3 speed.
The drives were Toshiba 3TB, about as fast a hard drive as can be found, delivering peak speed of 170 to 180MB/sec on the very fastest side of the drive, hence the most that can be expected is 340 - 360 MB/sec in a dual-drive RAID-0 stripe.
Performance for many tasks revolves around sustained transfer speed (e.g. saving large Photoshop files). Anything requiring very high transaction rates (many small reads and writes) is better approached with a fast SSD.
Both Thunderbolt and USB3 deliver to twice the speed of a single drive in a RAID-0 stripe configuration (very fast and as good as can be achieved).
USB3: 355, 358 write/read MB/sec
Thunderbolt: 344, 356 write/read MB/sec
USB3 performs marginally better than Thunderbolt, discussion continues below.
The Thunderbolt test was run twice; as shown this is the best-of-two runs (even a little more variation was seen with one run).
It turns out that USB is not only just as fast, but offers a slightly tighter performance envelope; the write speed variation with Thunderbolt is more (red line). In real world use, this is inconsequential.
Possible theory on Thunderbolt vs USB3 speed:
USB logic steps:
Drive > SATA to USB controller > USB cable > USB host/chipset
TB logic steps:
Drive > SATA to PCIe controller > TB controller > TB cable logic > cable > TB cable logic > TB Host controller